Current issue

C110 review

São Paulo: Bienal

Stephen Loughman: Untitled, 2000-2002, 91.5 x 213.5 cm, oil on canvas, courtesy Kevin Kavanagh Gallery

One hundred and thirty-five artists, fifty-five national representations, 670,000 visitors in 2002, the São Paulo Bienal is second only in the world to Venice, both in size and reputation. Unlike Venice, the vast majority of the work is housed in a single venue, the modernistic 25,000 square meters of the Oscar Niemeyer pavilion, an iconic structure in its own right. This Bienal is vast, a reflection perhaps of the heaving metropolis of the city itself, which at times makes Manhattan feel like Mullingar. As with all events of this size, the reputations and standards are mixed. This year's theme, 'Free Territory', evokes various dimensions, geographical, social, as well as the aesthetic - a theme, according to curator Alfons Hug, chosen "to enable a wide range of artistic positions to feel comfortable," or a vast and mixed array without a decisive curatorial voice?

Valeria Gonçalvez: Dennis McNulty in performance, São Paulo, 2004; courtesy Valeria Gonçalvez/AE

Ireland's entry, under the direction of Valerie Connor, consisted of three artistic contributions, from Stephen Loughman, Denis McNulty and desperate optimists (Christine Molloy and Joe Lawlor). Only Loughman's work was presented inside the Bienal building, an unusual move given that no real cohesive fringe events exist and many visitors seem loath to travel from the venue. Loughman's paintings in the Bienal portray wide-ranging subjects, including park scenes, museum displays and domestic space. They exist as independent works, but collectively address the representation of space as a subject matter. There is an underlying theatricality in these works, the settings for some unknown events, missed occasions, inviting the viewer's participation in the scene itself.

Denis McNulty's soundwork, part of the project http://alpha60.info, was performed at several venues in São Paulo, most notably at a public swimming pool designed by Icaro de Castro Mello and under the outdoor marquees in the park beside the Bienal building. Including recordings made in São Paulo, the piece was part soundwork, part performance, the artist altering various pitches and variations of the sound, creating a crescendoing wall of noise that filled the performance space. The settings for these performances added to the spectacle, the marquees creating a special stage for the artist, as the various park users sped by on rollerblades, bicycles and skateboards, becoming as much of a part of the performance as the movement of sound through the space.

 

 

 

desperate optimists: Civic life: Moore Street, 2004, film stills from 35mm anamorophic film, colour, sound, 5 min 25 sec; stills by Lip Sync Post, London; courtesy Artworking

desperate optimists', Civic life : Moore Street, is a 35mm, single tracking shot filmed on Moore Street on Dublin's Northside. It features members of Arambe, Dublin's first African theatre group, and touches on themes of emigration, belonging, exile and the city. The silent characters walk in the twilit street, the haunting voice of an African woman whispers to a loved one of her sense of loss in her self-impose exile. The street itself reflects the entrepreneurial spirit of the new migrants, with its various foodstores, restaurants, cutprice telephone and internet providers. Moore Street, although essential Dublin, becomes a generic city location, eerily quiet, uninhabited but for the silent figures. The setting is universal, just as are the poignant themes that this moving piece evokes. It will be shown in Dublin later this year and more than warrants a viewing.

Other highlights at the Bienal include Mike Nelson's architectural intervention, David Batchelor's neon sculpture, video and film work by Martin Sastre, Frederic Mosea and Philippe Schwinger, and Melik Ohania. Highlights in painting include Inka Essenhigh and Pablo Cardoso; the better photography comes from Alec Soth, Thomas Struth and a curated African photography section.

Ruth Carroll is exhibitions curator at the Royal Hibernian Academy, Dublin.

Bienal, São Paulo, September - December 2004

Article reproduced from CIRCA 110, Winter 2004, pp.92–93
Back to top of page

Do you have an opinion on this article? If so, please click here for our comments form.

No reader feedback so far - awaiting your input!


Marks - a new Circa / Stinging Fly collaborative publication

Survey of studio spaces in Dublin



Art-college survey: students/ lecturers/ tutors



Discounted Circa subscription rates



Please notify me about CIRCA-related acitvities; my e-mail address is:

It would also help us if you indicate your country of residence:

On sale now: Space: Architecture for Art, CIRCA's 272-page publication on the theory and practice of art spaces; incorporates an extensive directory of art spaces throughout Ireland. Click here for more information. Space cover


art ireland irish art
© Copyright 1999-2008
Circa Art Magazine
43/44 Temple Bar
Dublin 2, Ireland
Tel / Fax: +353 1 6797388
e-mail: info@recirca.com